• Loading ...
  • Loading ...

Accommodation New Zealand

TV judges reveal the most accurate court case movies ever made

26 Jan 2025 By foxnews

TV judges reveal the most accurate court case movies ever made

Accommodation New Zealand introduces

EXCLUSIVE - The judges who serve on Judge Judy's "Tribunal Justice" were asked which court case film is the most accurate they've ever seen, and one fan favorite kept popping up over all others.

Judges Adam Levy, son of Judge Judy, and Judge Patricia DiMango were in agreement that "My Cousin Vinny" has all the elements of a near-perfect court movie.

"My Cousin Vinny" is a 1992 comedy starring Joe Pesci as New York lawyer Vinny Gambini as he tries to win his first case. In the hit movie, Alabama authorities charge two innocent New York students for a convenience store murder, and the brash Gambini steps up to defend them.

JUDGE JUDY'S SON WANTS TO SEE LAWSUITS IN THE WAKE OF DEADLY LA FIRES: PUBLIC OFFICIALS 'PERSONALLY LIABLE'

The beloved movie also earned Marisa Tomei an Oscar for supporting actress for her role as Vinny's fast-talking Mona Lisa Vito, whose witness stand automobile expertise remains a classic comedy scene.

"'My Cousin Vinny,' bar none," Levy told Fox News Digital when asked to name the most on-point court movie he's ever seen. "Not only is it my favorite movie because - comedy or otherwise - it is one of the most accurate court movies besides the fact that you know, between the arrest and the trial takes all of about a week. Putting that aside, you had police investigations. You had pretrial hearings. You had jury selection. You had discovery issues."

In a legal case, discovery is the process of exchanging information and evidence between parties. And Levy said the film nailed it.

"You know, obviously, the Marisa Tomei line, 'It's called discovery, d---head,'" Levy continued. "You had direct examinations. You had vigorous cross-examinations. You had it all. You had expert witnesses. You had legal arguments. You had difficult judges who appeared to be one-sided. All of those things are exactly the way a trial takes place. At least in my experience."

DONALD TRUMP'S IMPEACHMENT ATTORNEY DRAWS COMPARISONS TO 'MY COUSIN VINNY' CHARACTER

DiMango agreed that "hands down, without a doubt," she'd also give the award to the classic comedy. 

"The movie itself tracks the statute from the time of arrest until the dismissal of the case," she told Fox News Digital. "And it does so in such a humorous way because there's such a twist to what some of the things that - like him coming to court in that absurd suit because he had to dress a certain way. After the opening statement, he's like falling asleep because he's so tired and they wake him up and he stands up."

"And I think he says, 'everything that guy said is bulls--t,' DiMango quoted Joe Pesci's character, laughing. "'Judge, that's argumentative. Strike that! And the judge says, 'strike everything but thank you.' You know, I mean, there's so much humor involved in it, from the confession, the opening statements, the magic grits. They really do punch holes and make fun of some serious stuff and the letter of the law. It can be distorted and made humorous and still be accurate."

'TRIBUNAL JUSTICE' JUDGES SHARE TIPS ON HOW TO TELL WHEN SOMEONE IS LYING

DiMango found the film so accurate that she actually used it as an instructional tool for the New York State Penal Law and Criminal Procedure law back when she was a college professor. 

"The students loved it," she recalled. "They would say, each class I had, they would say, 'Judge, you going to show us 'My Cousin Vinny?' And I'd say, 'yeah,' and you could pause on each different portion of the proceedings and bring them back to the criminal procedure law, bring them back to the penal law and talk about how the law applies and what it is."

Judge Tanya Acker, the third judge on "Tribunal Justice," said she was blown away by the 1990 Harrison Ford thriller "Presumed Innocent."

"I think that was just fire," she said. "Like, Harrison Ford did it right. Jake Gyllenhaal did it right. The plot twists are just so intricate and well-thought-out. I loved it. Loved it the first time. Love the remake."

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

"Tribunal Justice" season two is streaming on Prime Video starting on Monday. New episodes stream weekdays.

Are you looking for a holiday? Get special deals.

 

More News

Booking.com
Health tech breach exposes 3.4M patient records
Health tech breach exposes 3.4M patient records
NYC schools track bathroom time with digital hall passes
NYC schools track bathroom time with digital hall passes
Fox News AI Newsletter: Palantir CTO warns US has only 'eight days of weapons' in hypothetical China battle
Fox News AI Newsletter: Palantir CTO warns US has only 'eight days of weapons' in hypothetical China battle
Americans warned of potential attacks at vacation destination as border crossing exit fee doubles
Americans warned of potential attacks at vacation destination as border crossing exit fee doubles
Cannonball 'very likely' fired in 1836 Battle of the Alamo found buried near church
Cannonball 'very likely' fired in 1836 Battle of the Alamo found buried near church
Abandoned bear cub, 'under arrest for cuteness,' grabbed by state troopers from interstate highway
Abandoned bear cub, 'under arrest for cuteness,' grabbed by state troopers from interstate highway
Illegal immigrant, accomplice get 5 years for murder in sweetheart deal with progressive Virginia DA
Illegal immigrant, accomplice get 5 years for murder in sweetheart deal with progressive Virginia DA
Homan vows immigration mission 'won't skip a beat' as Bondi exits DOJ
Homan vows immigration mission 'won't skip a beat' as Bondi exits DOJ
Walmart employee fatally stabbed in random attack by man who allegedly believed victim was a 'demon': police
Walmart employee fatally stabbed in random attack by man who allegedly believed victim was a 'demon': police
Common drinking habit may quietly triple risk of advanced liver condition
Common drinking habit may quietly triple risk of advanced liver condition
Former Syracuse basketball player to be deported after spending weeks in ICE custody
Former Syracuse basketball player to be deported after spending weeks in ICE custody
Iran, proxy militias threaten US universities in Lebanon as Americans urged to flee now
Iran, proxy militias threaten US universities in Lebanon as Americans urged to flee now
Save Women's Sports activists thank Pam Bondi for Title IX enforcement after her departure from DOJ
Save Women's Sports activists thank Pam Bondi for Title IX enforcement after her departure from DOJ
Flight passengers are paying strangers to stand in long TSA lines as chaos drags on
Flight passengers are paying strangers to stand in long TSA lines as chaos drags on
Dementia may be signaled by common condition years before symptoms
Dementia may be signaled by common condition years before symptoms
Jamie Lee Curtis blasts Hollywood 'fakery,' says plastic surgery made her feel 'fraudulent'
Jamie Lee Curtis blasts Hollywood 'fakery,' says plastic surgery made her feel 'fraudulent'
Parents of MacDill bomb suspects are illegal immigrants, DHS warns of birthright citizenship dangers
Parents of MacDill bomb suspects are illegal immigrants, DHS warns of birthright citizenship dangers
Truth about Arizona girl found alive decades after vanishing leaves investigator 'dumbfounded': report
Truth about Arizona girl found alive decades after vanishing leaves investigator 'dumbfounded': report
Newsom office called out for skipping Biden in post missing Obama as past president with 'functioning brain'
Newsom office called out for skipping Biden in post missing Obama as past president with 'functioning brain'
Dem Senator warns of NFL Draft security risks amid Iran war in letter to DHS
Dem Senator warns of NFL Draft security risks amid Iran war in letter to DHS